ETF catalog
Change funds

TRUD vs XLYETF Holdings Overlap

TRUD VanEck Consumer Discretionary TruSector ETFXLY State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF
Weighted overlap33.76% Moderate

For each shared stock, we take the smaller of its two fund weights. Adding those weights gives the overall overlap.

See a simple example

Amazon.com Inc represents 24.66% of TRUD and 22.22% of XLY. The smaller weight, 22.22 percentage points, goes into the total overlap.

What does the rating mean?

In shared stocks

TRUD36.20%

Of TRUD, in shares also held by XLY.

47 of 48 matched share classes are shared

XLY99.90%

Of XLY, in shares also held by TRUD.

47 of 47 matched share classes are shared

Change funds

Search by ticker or fund name.

VanEck Consumer Discretionary TruSector ETF

State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF

Overlap history

Change over the displayed period4 portfolio dates
–
Weighted overlap
29.02% → 33.76%+4.74 pp
Shared stock classes
4 → 47+43
Weighted overlap
Weight (%)
Portfolio date
Shared stock classes
Stock classes
Portfolio date

Hover or tap a point for both values. Use arrow keys, Home or End to choose a date. Gaps mark dates without verified data.

See all 4 dates and SEC filings
DateWeight (%)ClassesSEC
33.76%47 TRUD XLY
46.78%48 TRUD XLY
29.74%4 TRUD XLY
29.02%4 TRUD XLY
Methodology

We add the smaller weight of each shared common-stock share class. Weights use each fund’s net assets as reported. We omit dates without a same-day pair of reviewed filings or below 90% matched assets in either fund.

The minimum matched share of net assets was 99.89%. Filings were submitted 52–59 days after their portfolio dates. The archive confirms filing dates. Exact public release times are unavailable. The reviewed series ends on .

Methodology

What changed between filings

→ -13.02 pp
NameContribution to change
Tesla Inc-1.75 pp
Amazon.com Inc-1.31 pp
McDonald's Corp-1.04 pp
Booking Holdings Inc-0.93 pp
Home Depot Inc/The-0.68 pp
All other shared classes-7.29 pp

These are the largest changes in overlap contribution. A difference in reported weights does not establish a trade.

Filing sources

Read the dates and how much of each fund we could compare.

MeasureTRUDXLY
Holdings date
Filed
Matched (%)99.99%99.90%
SEC filingSECSEC
What do these numbers mean?

Holdings date · The day the fund recorded its holdings.

Matched (%) · The share of the fund’s net assets that we could identify as common-stock classes.

Inside the two funds

Largest shared positions

Showing the top 3 of 47 matched stock classes.

Name TRUD · Portfolio weightXLY · Portfolio weight Shared weight
Amazon.com Inc24.66%22.22%22.22%
Tesla Inc7.18%19.64%7.18%
Home Depot Inc/The2.13%5.83%2.13%

Each shared weight is the smaller of the two fund weights for that stock. Adding these amounts across all shared stocks gives the total overlap.

Only in TRUD

Showing the top 1 of 1 matched stock classes.

NameTRUD · Portfolio weight
State Street Consumer Discretionary Select Sector SPDR ETF63.79%

Only in XLY

No matched stock classes in this group for the selected date.

See full holdings report options

Overlap by industry

See how many percentage points each industry adds to the 33.76% overlap.

IndustriesContribution (pp)
Retail 24.91
Manufacturing 7.18
Transport, communications and utilities 0.10
Unknown industry 1.58

Broad groups based on SEC industry codes (SIC). An industry is unknown when we could not verify its code. Rounded values may add up to a slightly different total.

Industry weights by fund

Each column shows the share of that fund’s net assets in matched stocks in the industry. The difference is in percentage points.

IndustriesTRUD · Portfolio weightXLY · Portfolio weightWeight difference in percentage points
Manufacturing 7.18%19.64% -12.46
Retail 27.34%32.20% -4.86
Transport, communications and utilities 0.10%3.44% -3.34
Unknown industry 65.37%44.62% +20.75

Difference = TRUD minus XLY. Broad groups based on SEC industry codes (SIC). An industry is unknown when we could not verify its code.